ICC interfering in BCCI's
affairs: Dalmiya
Barely two days ahead of the Annual General Meeting of the Board of Control for Cricket in India, board president Jagmohan Dalmiya accused the International Cricket Council of interfering
in the internal affairs of the BCCI and pressurising its secretary to sign the controversial Champions Trophy agreement.
In a letter faxed to ICC president Malcolm Gray, Dalmiya, referring to recent media reports, said, "From the tone of these reports it appears that the ICC president and the ICC
chief executive [Malcolm Speed] are interfering with the
internal affairs of the BCCI."
He also claimed that BCCI secretary Niranjan Shah was pressurised to sign the Participating Nation's Agreement (PNA) for the Champions Trophy during several telephone discussions with ICC oficials.
Emphasising that statements attributed to the ICC
bosses are not only "factually incorrect but also have serious
ramifications", Dalmiya urged world cricket's governing
body to issue a denial on the media reports.
Dalmiya's strong reaction came after media reports quoted
Gray as saying that the controversial Players' Terms, which
had led to the recent standoff between the BCCI and top players, had been signed by the present board chief and not by his predecessor A C Muthiah.
Incidentally, the sponsorship controversy centering
around the Players' Terms is expected to figure prominently in
the two-day AGM, beginning on Thursday.
Contending that the Participating Nations' Agreement could
not have been signed in December last year when he was in
office, Dalmiya referred to the minutes of the ICC Cricket
Committee (Management) meeting on February 10, 2002, at Christchurch
to buttress his point.
'It was also noted that IDI was in the process of
producing the Host Agreement and would hold detailed
operational discussions in Sri Lanka in early March 2002. It
was noted that the Participating Nations Agreement for the
event would be sent to the teams by the end of March and that
a signed copy is required to be returned within 45 days,' the
letter said, quoting the minutes.
"If this was the discussion in the ICC Cricket Committee
(Management) meeting in February, there could be no question
of signing the PNA for the Champions Trophy in December, 2001. In
fact, the PNA for the tournament was received by the BCCI
secretary some time in April 2002," Dalmiya
said in the missive.
He said that on receiving the PNA, the BCCI had noted
certain objectional clauses and took legal opinion on them.
Claiming that the BCCI secretary was pressurised to sign
the PNA, Dalmiya said: "When he [Shah] said that certain
clauses are not acceptable, he was told that he was bound to
sign the PNA because the BCCI had already signed the Cricket
Events Agreement in May last year."
The letter said that under the circumstances, the BCCI
secretary signed the PNA on June 22 this year, but "under very
strong protest".
Dalmiya said Shah had then written to the ICC that it
would not be possible for the Indian board to agree to certain
provisions of the PNA, including the controversial conflicting
advertisement clause 13 barring players from endorsing
products potentially in conflict with those of official
sponsors during and 30 days on either side of ICC tournaments.
"We do not interfere with such rights of the players
because it directly affects their Fundamental Rights under the
Constitution of India," Dalmiya wrote in the letter, quoting
Shah's missive to the ICC on June 22.
Dalmiya also claimed that the BCCI is perhaps the only board
to have signed the PNA for the Champions Trophy 'conditionally
and under protest'.
The BCCI chief requested Gray to confirm the sequence of
events as mentioned in the letter, "contrary to what is
published in a section of the media quoting you as ICC
president or the Chief Executive [Speed]".
Stressing that such "wrong reportage" is creating a lot
of confusion, Dalmiya said: "This is further compounded by
quotes from you and the ICC Chief Executive."
"It would perhaps be beneficial for all concerned if the
ICC issues a media release contradicting the reports," he
added.
Mail Cricket Editor